Fruit and Blood Sugar - Myths & Facts

Fruit is often the subject of debate when it comes to diet and blood sugar regulation. Some claim that fructose is just as harmful as refined sugar, while others emphasize the health benefits of fruit. But what does the science actually say?

One of the most common misconceptions is that all sugar sources affect the body in the same way. However, there are significant differences between the natural sugars found in whole fruits and the refined carbohydrates in processed foods.

In this article, we address some of the most frequently asked questions:

• Does fruit cause significant insulin spikes?

• Are fruit juices really worse than whole fruits?

• How do dietary fibres influence sugar absorption?

Drawing on scientific research, we will clarify the role of fruit in a blood sugar-friendly diet.

Insulin Spikes After Eating - What Happens in the Body?

After every meal, blood sugar levels naturally rise - this is a normal physiological response. During digestion, carbohydrates are broken down into glucose, which enters the bloodstream and provides energy to the body's cells.

Insulin: The Key Hormone

As blood sugar levels increase, the pancreas releases insulin. This hormone ensures that glucose moves from the bloodstream into the cells, where it is used for energy or stored. This process helps blood sugar return to a normal level.

When Do Insulin Spikes Become a Problem?

A moderate increase in insulin is completely normal and not harmful - especially when the body responds with an efficient insulin release. However, issues arise when:

• Insulin spikes are too high or prolonged.

• Excessive insulin release causes rapid blood sugar drops, leading to fatigue and cravings.

• The body develops insulin resistance, meaning it no longer responds effectively to insulin, which can increase the long-term risk of diabetes.

Fruit vs. Processed Carbohydrates - The Key Difference

Many people equate fruit sugar with industrially processed sugar, but the body processes these sugars differently. While refined sugars in processed foods often cause sharp insulin spikes, whole fruits have a different effect on metabolism.

Why Are Whole Fruits Healthier Than Processed Foods Containing Sugar?

• Lower Glycemic Load - Fruit has a lower glycemic load than white bread, sugary drinks, or sweets.

• Fibre Slows Down Sugar Absorption - The natural fibre in fruit helps prevent rapid spikes in blood sugar.

• Additional Nutrients - Fruit contains phytonutrients, vitamins, and antioxidants that support metabolism.

Example: One hundred percent fruit juice causes a more moderate blood sugar response than sugary soft drinks because it still contains natural fructose, vitamins, and phytonutrients. However, it lacks the fibre found in whole fruit, which plays a protective role.

Fibre and Blood Sugar - Why an Apple is Better Than Apple Juice

The fibre content of fruit plays a key role in blood sugar regulation. While whole fruits contain valuable fibre that slows down sugar absorption, these fibres are largely lost in processed forms such as applesauce or apple juice.

A direct comparison highlights these differences:

• Whole Apples - Contain all fibres, helping to slow down the rise in blood sugar.

• Applesauce - Already processed, lacks skin, and has fewer intact fibres, leading to a stronger blood sugar response.

• Apple Juice - No fibres left, allowing sugar to enter the bloodstream quickly, causing a sharp insulin spike.

Scientific studies confirm that the physical form of fruit significantly influences blood sugar responses. One study found that adding fibre-rich fruit pulp (orange pomace) to a carbohydrate-rich meal reduced the blood sugar response by 36 percent.

To avoid sharp insulin spikes, whole fruits should always be the preferred choice. Smoothies can also be a better alternative to fruit juices, as long as the entire fruit, including its skin and fibre, is blended.

The Right Time to Eat Fruit: When is Best?

In addition to the type of fruit, the timing of consumption can also influence the body’s blood sugar response. The metabolism follows a circadian rhythm, which affects how nutrients are processed.

Does the Time of Day Affect Blood Sugar Response?

Studies suggest that the body’s blood sugar response to the same meal is often stronger in the morning than in the evening.

A 2022 study using continuous glucose monitoring found:

• Identical snacks in the morning led to higher insulin spikes compared to the evening.

• In the evening, the rise in blood sugar was more gradual and lasted longer.

• This challenges previous assumptions that carbohydrates are processed more efficiently in the morning.

However, in everyday situations, this difference is relatively minor for healthy individuals.

Fruit Before or After a Meal - Which is Better?

The order in which foods are consumed also affects blood sugar levels. A study with healthy adults found that eating fruit before a carbohydrate-rich meal - such as rice - reduced the blood sugar response by up to 46 percent.

This effect is due to the role of dietary fibre, which slows down gastric emptying, thereby reducing the absorption of sugar from the subsequent meal.

For those looking to minimise blood sugar spikes, fruit should ideally be eaten as a starter before a meal or in combination with protein and healthy fats. Research suggests that pairing fruit with proteins or fibres leads to a more stable blood sugar response compared to consuming fruit alone.

Smoothies - Blood Sugar Friendly or Not?

Smoothies are often promoted as a healthy alternative to whole fruits, but concerns remain about their impact on blood sugar levels. A common belief is that blending fruit leads to faster sugar absorption, resulting in stronger insulin spikes. However, scientific studies suggest otherwise.

Does Blending Fruit Lead to a Stronger Blood Sugar Response?

A widely held misconception is that smoothies cause a faster rise in blood sugar compared to eating whole fruits. The assumption behind this is that blending breaks down the cell structures of fruit, making sugar more readily available for absorption.

However, multiple studies have investigated this theory. A 2022 study compared blood sugar responses after consuming whole fruits and smoothies made from the same fruits. The surprising result: the smoothie produced a similar or even lower blood sugar response than eating whole fruits.

One possible explanation is that blending does not remove fibre from certain fruits but can make some fibres more accessible. This is particularly true for berries, which contain small, hard-to-digest seeds. Research suggests that breaking down these seeds enhances the release of fibre and phytonutrients, which in turn slow sugar absorption.

For a smoothie to have the same benefits as whole fruit, it must be made from whole, unprocessed fruits. A pure fruit juice or a smoothie with added sugar does not offer the same advantages. Portion size also matters, as smoothies often contain multiple fruits, increasing the total sugar content compared to eating a single piece of fruit.

Are Fruits Suitable for People with Diabetes?

People with diabetes or insulin resistance are often advised to avoid fruit due to its sugar content. However, scientific research suggests that this advice is not only unnecessary but may even be counterproductive.

Myth: Fruit is Bad for People with Diabetes

A randomised study involving individuals with type 2 diabetes compared two groups:

• One group significantly reduced fruit intake.

• The other group continued to eat fruit regularly.

After several weeks, there was no difference in long-term blood sugar levels (HbA1c) between the two groups. This means that moderate fruit consumption does not negatively impact blood sugar control.

A comprehensive 2023 review reached a similar conclusion: fruit improves glucose metabolism in both healthy individuals and people with diabetes rather than worsening it. Additionally, fruit was found to have positive effects on inflammation markers and blood lipid levels.

Which Fruits Are Best?

For people with diabetes or insulin resistance, fibre-rich, low-glycaemic fruits are the best choice, as they lead to a slower rise in blood sugar levels. These include:

• Berries (strawberries, blueberries, raspberries)

• Apples and pears

• Citrus fruits (oranges, grapefruit)

• Cherries

On the other hand, dried fruits and high-sugar fruits such as grapes, bananas, and pineapple should be consumed in smaller amounts or paired with protein and healthy fats to slow down the blood sugar response.

Blood Sugar-Friendly Nutrition with Fruit - Practical Tips

Fruit is a valuable part of a healthy diet. Its fibre, vitamins, and phytonutrients provide numerous health benefits. However, the way fruit is consumed can affect blood sugar levels differently. The following tips will help you maximize the benefits of fruit while avoiding insulin spikes.

1. Choose Whole Fruits Over Fruit Juices

Studies show that consuming whole fruits leads to a more moderate blood sugar response compared to fruit juices. An apple or an orange causes a slower rise in blood sugar than a glass of apple juice or orange juice. To minimise blood sugar spikes, whole fruits should always be the preferred choice over juices.

2. Combine Fruit with Fibre, Protein, or Healthy Fats

Pairing fruit with other nutrients can help keep blood sugar levels more stable. Protein and healthy fats slow the absorption of sugar into the bloodstream, preventing sharp spikes.

Good combinations include:

• Fruit with nuts, nut butter, or seeds (e.g., almonds, walnuts, or chia seeds)

• Fruit with high-protein yogurt or cottage cheese

• Smoothies with protein powder and flax or hemp seeds

The reason for this recommendation lies in digestion timing: Combining fruit with fat or protein slows down sugar absorption, ensuring more sustained energy release.

Conclusion: No Need to Fear Fruit Sugar

Fruit has unfairly gained a bad reputation when it comes to blood sugar management. However, research shows that whole fruits do not cause dangerous blood sugar spikes. On the contrary:

• Fruits are a healthy carbohydrate source, containing fibre, phytonutrients, and natural sugars.

• The fibre in fruit slows sugar absorption, leading to a more stable blood sugar response.

• People with diabetes or insulin resistance can benefit from moderate fruit consumption, as long as they eat fruit in its whole form.

To avoid blood sugar spikes, it is important to limit processed carbohydrates, but there is no need to fear whole fruits. They are not only nutritious but also support a balanced and sustainable diet.

With conscious food choices and smart combinations, blood sugar can be naturally stabilised - without giving up fresh fruit.

Sources

[1] Viguiliouk E, Jenkins AL, Blanco Mejia S, Sievenpiper JL, Kendall CWC. Effect of dried fruit on postprandial glycemia: a randomized acute-feeding trial. Nutr Diabetes. 2018 Dec 11;8(1):59.

[2] Robayo S, Kucab M, Walker SE, Suitor K, D'Aversa K, Morello O, Bellissimo N. Effect of 100% Orange Juice and a Volume-Matched Sugar-Sweetened Drink on Subjective Appetite, Food Intake, and Glycemic Response in Adults. Nutrients. 2024 Jan 12;16(2):242.

[3] Dreher ML. Whole Fruits and Fruit Fiber Emerging Health Effects. Nutrients. 2018 Nov 28;10(12):1833.

[4] Timmer R, Bogaardt L, Brummelhuis WJ, van Oostrom CT, van Kerkhof LWM, Wong A, de Valk HW, Ocké MC, van der Maaden T, Dollé MET. A randomized crossover trial assessing time of day snack consumption and resulting postprandial glycemic response in a real-life setting among healthy adults. Chronobiol Int. 2022 Oct;39(10):1329-1339.

[5] Lu X, Lu J, Fan Z, Liu A, Zhao W, Wu Y, Zhu R. Both Isocarbohydrate and Hypercarbohydrate Fruit Preloads Curbed Postprandial Glycemic Excursion in Healthy Subjects. Nutrients. 2021 Jul 19;13(7):2470.

[6] Crummett LT, Grosso RJ. Postprandial Glycemic Response to Whole Fruit versus Blended Fruit in Healthy, Young Adults. Nutrients. 2022 Oct 30;14(21):4565.

[7] Redfern KM, Cammack VL, Sweet N, Preston LA; SoBHCS Student Team; Jarvis MA, Rees GA. Nutrient-extraction blender preparation reduces postprandial glucose responses from fruit juice consumption. Nutr Diabetes. 2017 Oct 9;7(10):e288.

[8] Ellouze I, Akhavan N, Singar S, Dawkins K, Nagpal R, Arjmandi B. The Relationship of Fruits and Fruit-Products Consumption with Glucose Homeostasis and Diabetes: A Comprehensive Update on the Current Clinical Literature. Dietetics. 2023; 2(3):237-266.